I’m having this trouble too. After seeing the last post here, though, I’m unclear what the solution is. I’m using eMember v4.9.4 and WP2.9.2.
I’ve protected Pages and Categories with General Protection. I’ve granted access to the Basic membership level to the individual Pages and Categories.
When logged in as a Basic member, I can view the blog page, but receive the same “Your membership level does not allow you to view rest of content.” for the Posts.
Any help is greatly appreciated. So, thanks.