Hi! Thank you for your quick response!
I got your email. I’m not sure how to have you try to recreate the problem without paying for a membership and/or renewal.
I don’t have the manual approval feature checked, but new and renewing members are set to ‘inactive’. I have not done any customization to the plugin. Do you think it would be helpful to reinstall the plugin and/or create a debug file while I go through the steps of purchasing/renewing a membership? I can just pay and refund the payment to myself.